[Trigger Warning: Discussion of offensive portrayals / stereotypes of the mentally ill]

Andrew, who runs the wonderful zine ilivesweat (check it out!) gave me a heads up on this interesting and important article about DC Comics’ portrayal of the mentally ill (particularly those with psychotic diagnoses). 

The role of the media in encouraging stigmatizing attitudes towards the mentally ill should not be underestimated - especially comics, which have a high readership of adolescents (an age range at which psychotic symptoms most often first present). Media presentations may shape not only the behaviours of the public but also inadvertently the reactions of the disordered themselves: Link et al (1999) suggest that the very act of perceiving the mentally ill as dangerous translates to fact regardless of contrary evidence because “If men define situations as real, they are real in their consequences”, (Thomas & Thomas, 1928).

Greg et al (1994) analysed UK media content during a one month period and found that two thirds of items dealing with mental health issues forged a link to violence. Two fifths of participants believed mental illness to be associated with violence and cited the media as their source. Some even accepted this view against personal evidence. Not only are violent stereotypes a concern, but also moralistic and demonising interpretations of senseless crimes as indicative of a sinful nature (Corrigan & Watson, 2005).

Consistently maligning the mentally ill as deviant, violent, evil, and determined to overthrow or hurt the ‘good guys’ (i.e. the neurotypical) serves to stigmatise and further alienate the mentally ill from mainstream society. It constructs a culture of shame around mental illness. It deters the mentally ill from seeking help. It pushes them into struggling alone. It is offensive. It is unnecessary.

Why can’t the explanatory narrative surrounding ‘bad guys’ in comics be that they are just bad? Why do they have to be mentally ill? Why can’t more of the good guys (like Starman) be mentally ill? (“The way it’s depicted so often with villains is that the guy is bad because of his mental illness. That mental illness completely defines him, and that’s just not how it is in real life.”)

We should remember that the mentally ill are more likely to be victims than perpetrators of violent crimes, and this is no doubt at least partially because media portrayals of them as other, deviant, violent, amoral or evil makes them targets of attacks.

Notes

  1. signsofmentalillness reblogged this from mindovermatterzine
  2. maesaslaw reblogged this from insane-in-the-meninges and added:
    1) What does that make Hamlet? Or Ophelia? Or Captain Ahab? Or any other canonical character with a demonstrable mental...
  3. ribenaandxmas reblogged this from tuuli
  4. maesaslaw reblogged this from mindovermatterzine and added:
    Hello Internet. So I reblogged this from some random browsing and didn’t expect...hear...
  5. stepfwd reblogged this from mindovermatterzine and added:
    normalize… Definitely thought about the second posit today. If...were able to have “wild...
  6. parsingthoughts reblogged this from briefbutstillinfinite
  7. briefbutstillinfinite reblogged this from mindovermatterzine and added:
    signal boost for a response - I don’t even know how to start
  8. myasphyxiatedmind reblogged this from mindovermatterzine
  9. mindovermatterzine reblogged this from insane-in-the-meninges and added:
    Anyone else got opinions on this?
  10. insane-in-the-meninges reblogged this from mindovermatterzine and added:
    have two posits: 1) People will always always always...stories about crazy* people doing...
  11. mindovermatterzine reblogged this from maesaslaw and added:
    I’m publishing this here for my followers to comment on amongst themselves as, right now, I’m out of spoons.
  12. maesaslaw reblogged this from mindovermatterzine and added:
    Edify me, #1: Is...gist that it’s no longer okay to make art in which
  13. yesyasmin reblogged this from abigailsparty
  14. abigailsparty reblogged this from postponelife
  15. altaeousverte reblogged this from mindovermatterzine
  16. colourofpanic reblogged this from ilivesweat
  17. tuuli reblogged this from goldenliliesqueen
  18. goldenliliesqueen reblogged this from mindovermatterzine
  19. queerinterspace reblogged this from mindovermatterzine
  20. championmediocrity reblogged this from r-har
  21. inspe reblogged this from mindovermatterzine
  22. r-har reblogged this from ilivesweat
  23. xdoriangray reblogged this from ilivesweat
  24. containeder reblogged this from mindovermatterzine
  25. postponelife reblogged this from ilivesweat
  26. lindseydreadfuls reblogged this from ilivesweat
  27. roisinblah reblogged this from mindovermatterzine and added:
    I’ve always felt really guilty playing Batman XBox games. They’re so fucked up,
  28. cicada-san reblogged this from mindovermatterzine
  29. ilivesweat reblogged this from mindovermatterzine and added:
    reading Mind Over Matter, you ought...be, especially if you’re interested
  30. mindovermatterzine posted this